Last updated April 28, 2024

Best Medicare Supplement Providers 2024

Medicare comparison made simple

Where Can You Find the Best Medicare Supplement Company?

Did you Know?
• Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) covers most, but not all, of the health care costs you may face. Medicare Supplement Insurance, also called Medigap, helps fill the "gaps" to mitigate your costs, and offer peace of mind.
• Supplement policy holders can see any doctor who accepts Medicare patients —including those out of state.
• Supplement coverage goes with you anywhere you travel in the United States and is guaranteed for life if premiums are paid on time.
See our favorite Supplement companies below.
1
 Best Rated Award
logo-united-medicare-advisors-200 (1)
9.8

United Medicare Advisors

Medicare Shopping Made Easy

  • More than 30,000 Five-Star Reviews
  • A+ BBB Rating
  • Average Savings of $581 Annually
Humana Logo
9.6

Humana

See how Humana plans put you first

  • Variety of Plans
  • User-Friendly Website
  • Plans Available in All 50 States
Cigna-Logo-1024x576-1
9.5

Cigna

Together, all the way®

  • Available in 48 states
  • 24 Hour Customer Support
  • Easy-to-Use Website
logo-aetna-200
9.4

Aetna

Healthier happens together

  • Online and over-the-phone quotes
  • Helpful online content
  • Long-standing, stable company
ps-logo
8.8

Policy Scout

Compare Insurance Online at PolicyScout

  • Convenient Online Platform
  • Ability to Compare Many Options
  • Unbiased Resources
AARP-Logo-500x313
8.2

AARP

Empowering people to choose how they live as they age

  • Straightforward website
  • Convenient quotes
  • Great customer service
Mutual-of-Omaha-logo
8.0

Mutual of Omaha

Whether you’re new to Medicare or want to find a better solution, we’re here to help

  • Competitive Rates
  • Strong Reputation
  • Good Customer Service
GoHealth_Logo
7.9

GoHealth

Discover Affordable Medicare Health & Insurance Plans

  • Friendly Customer Service
  • Good Reputation
  • Affordable Plans
logo-go-medigap-200
7.6

GoMedigap

A simpler way to shop for Medicare

  • Free to shoppers
  • Easy-to-use website
  • Offers plans from 30+ insurance carriers
Medicare Nationwide Logo
7.3

Medicare Nationwide Insurance Agency

Best Medicare Supplement Plans

  • Variety of Options
  • Helpful Information Resources
  • Easy-to-Use Website

Our Best Overall Choice

1
 Best Rated Award
logo-united-medicare-advisors-200 (1)
9.8

United Medicare Advisors

Medicare Shopping Made Easy

  • More than 30,000 Five-Star Reviews
  • A+ BBB Rating
  • Average Savings of $581 Annually

Why Medicare Supplement Insurance?

Having Medicare Supplement Insurance (also called Medigap) in addition to Original Medicare benefits helps to protect you from unexpected costs, allowing you to receive the care you need without worry of financial burden. Because of the guaranteed coverage protection offered during the Open Enrollment Period, it's a great option for those with pre-existing conditions as well. Plus, it allows you to continue to receive the federal Medicare benefits you’ve been paying toward throughout your working years.

 

Key advantages of Medicare Supplement Insurance:

  • Guaranteed renewability each year

As long as you pay your premium, your coverage will continue year after year and cannot be cancelled (except in specific cases, like providing inaccurate information on your application).

  • Simple, straightforward plan options

Because they are federally standardized, it’s fairly straightforward to understand and compare your options when it comes to Medigap coverage.

  • Nationwide network of doctors and specialists

Medicare Supplement enrollees can visit any doctor that accepts Medicare coverage. Doctors or hospitals that accept Medicare are required to accept all Medigap plans, regardless of insurance carrier.

  • More flexibility with treatment options. 

Some Medicare plans require you to choose a primary care physician, who has the final say on what providers you can see. Medigap plans allow you the flexibility to select any treatment option you prefer.